Iran Chabahar port, and its imperative for India (GS Paper 2, International Relation)
Why in news?
- During this visit to Iran, External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar held discussions on establishing a long-term cooperation framework for the Chabahar port in the south of the country.
Why it matters?
- Chabahar, which sits at the mouth of the Gulf of Oman, is Iran’s first deepwater port that puts the country on the global oceanic trade route map.
- The port lies to the west of Iran’s border with Pakistan, about as far as Gwadar, a competing port developed by China in Pakistan, lies to the east of the border.
- Chabahar is of strategic importance to both Iran and India. It can potentially help Iran ward off the effect of Western sanctions, and offers India an alternative route that bypasses Pakistan, which does not allow India land access for trade with Afghanistan and Central Asia.
- The port is also part of the proposed International North-South Transport Corridor (INSTC), a multi-modal transportation project linking the Indian Ocean and Persian Gulf to the Caspian Sea via Iran, and onward to northern Europe via St Petersburg in Russia.
What is the nature of India’s involvement in the Chabahar port?
- India’s involvement in the development of the port began in 2002, when Hassan Rouhani, then National Security Advisor to President Syed Mohammad Khatami, held discussions with his Indian counterpart, Brajesh Mishra.
- On President Khatami’s visit to India the following year, he and Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee signed a roadmap of strategic cooperation, one of the key projects in which was Chabahar.
Historical aspect:
- The emergence of a hostile Pakistan after Partition severed India’s land connections with Iran and Central Asia. This, however, did not greatly impact India’s closed economy in the four decades that followed Independence.
- India and Iran began to cooperate more closely once the Taliban took over Afghanistan in 1996. Both countries were against the Pakistan-created Sunni Islamist militia, and backed the Northern Alliance led by Ahmed Shah Massoud.
Alternative route:
- As India sought to get past the Pakistani block on land transit access to Afghanistan, the search for an alternative route became more urgent.
- The easiest routes for India to Central Asia and Russia are through Pakistan and Afghanistan. The next best is through Iran, which borders Central Asia and the Caspian Sea. Even as India sought access to Afghanistan, it was also looking at what was called the INSTC, which would take it to Russia and the European territories.
- The Chabahar project became even more important for India after China began to develop the Gwadar port in Pakistan as part of the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI).
How much of the Chabahar port has been developed?
- There are two distinct ports in the Chabahar project, Shahid Beheshti and Shahid Kalantari.
- India’s investment is restricted to the Shahid Beheshti port.
- India, Iran, and Afghanistan signed a trilateral agreement in April 2016, after which the Indian Shipping Ministry worked at a rapid pace towards developing the port.
- In December 2017, the first phase of Shahid Beheshti port was inaugurated, and India sent its first consignment of wheat to Afghanistan through Chabahar that same year.
- Two years later, Afghan exports to India passed through the port for the first time. India received four such consignments that year.
IPGL incorporation:
- In January 2015, India Ports Global Limited (IPGL) was incorporated under the Companies Act, 2013, for the development of ports overseas. In December 2018, IPGL took over a part of the operations at Shahid Beheshti.
- The Shahid Beheshti port is being developed in four phases. “On completion of all 4 phases, port capacity will (be) 82 million tons per year with 32 jetties: 16 multipurpose, 10 containers, 3 each oil and dry bulk.
- In December 2019, the Iranian Minister for Roads and Urban Planning announced that the construction of a modern cruise terminal in the first phase had increased the capacity of the Shahid Beheshti port to 5.8 million tonnes.
But why is it taking so long to develop the port?
- India has traditionally had trouble implementing ambitious infrastructure projects in its neighbourhood.
- The geopolitical roadblocks, the biggest of which is Iran’s relationship with the US, have been the major reason for the delay.
- After the 2003 Vajpayee-Khatami agreement, follow-up action was slow as India drew closer to the administration of President George W Bush. The US had put Iran in the so-called “axis of evil” along with Saddam Hussein’s Iraq and Kim Jong-Il’s North Korea which put pressure on India to go slow in its relationship with Iran.
- The US-Iran relationship started to improve temporarily after the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) was signed between Iran and the P5+1 and the European Union in 2015 when Barack Obama and Rouhani were Presidents.
- The Donald Trump administration, however, walked the US out of the Iran nuclear deal in 2018, and imposed sanctions on dealing with Iran. A “carve-out” was provided to India for Chabahar, but it was difficult under the sanctions regime to find international suppliers for the material required to develop the port.
- The US exit from Afghanistan and the return to power of the Taliban in August 2021 came as a further blow as India snapped ties with Kabul. The situation has improved since, in 2022, India reopened its embassy in Kabul and announced Rs 200 crore of development assistance to Afghanistan.
- India also allocated Rs 100 crore for the Chabahar port project, and said in 2023 that it would send 20,000 metric tonnes of wheat to Afghanistan through the port.
What happens in the project here onward?
- The pace of development of Chabahar port will be impacted by US-Iran ties, which have been deteriorating steadily and could worsen dramatically in the event of Trump returning to the White House early next year.
- The ongoing crisis in the Red Sea, a spillover of the Israel-Hamas conflict in Gaza, has made the situation in the entire region extremely volatile and unpredictable. Since November 2022, Yemen’s Houthi militia, which Iran backs, has harassed commercial vessels passing through this major global shipping lane, drawing retaliatory strikes by the US and the UK.
- The recent tit-for-tat missile strikes by Iran and Pakistan targeting militant bases in each other’s territory marked an escalation in an unexpected direction, the full implications of which remain to be seen.
- India has said it has zero tolerance for terror and the Houthi attacks on commercial vessels harm its interests. But after the Iranian cross-border strikes in Pakistan, it also acknowledged that countries need to take actions “in their self defence”.
Way Forward:
- The Chabahar project comes with its challenges, mainly susceptibility to American sanctions and pressures, the volatility and continuing uncertainties in Afghanistan, and the seeming incompatibility with the BRI.
- However, through active and visionary diplomacy and efficient implementation and operations of the project, Iran and India can overcome these challenges and should be able to maintain the Chabahar project as a viable transit hub and link.
